Amish Chicken Casserole uses flavor packed rotisserie chicken as a base and is topped with a savory and simple white sauce and perfectly cooked noodles.
Amish Chicken Casserole
A simple and delicious chicken casserole with an incredibly easy white sauce, this Amish Chicken Casserole makes the perfect supper to come home to. After a hard day’s work, we can’t shovel it down fast enough and always wish we made more! We like to use egg noodles, homemade or store-bought, but feel free to use any type of shortcut pasta you prefer.
How to make Chicken Casserole
One of my favorite things about this recipe is that it calls for rotisserie chicken. There is really no better way to prepare chicken than rotisserie style, in my humble opinion. You can use my slow cooker rotisserie chicken recipe if you want, or run to the local grocery store and grab the already made version. Rotisserie chicken is juicy and full of flavor. You will not regret making it yourself if you give it a try! The recipe above also uses carrots and potatoes. When I just want the chicken, I will use crumpled tin foil balls to keep the chicken elevated while it cooks, giving it that amazing rotisserie taste.
To prepare Amish Chicken Casserole you will first make the sauce. Melt some butter and make a roux by adding flour. Whisk it around just enough to remove the lumps and brown it a bit. Stir in your broth and milk and let it come to a boil until the sauce has thickened. Add some salt and pepper to taste and then set the burner to the lowest level of heat. You will want to keep an eye on the sauce and may want to whisk it every now and then. It will continue to thicken.
In a large bowl, combine your chicken, mushrooms, onions, parsley and cooked noodles. Pour the sauce over the top and stir it all up to coat. Pour the whole bowl into a greased baking dish, top with some freshly grated parmesan cheese and pop it in the oven for 25-30 minutes or until it is cooked through completely.
Chicken Noodle Casserole
The egg noodles are also a staple ingredient in the recipe. Now you CAN go to the store and buy your own bag of premade egg noodles. That would be the easy route. The more rewarding route though? Just make them yourself! Egg noodles are incredibly easy to make and the flavor is so much better. Here is a recipe for homemade egg noodles. Just five simple ingredients (that you probably already have) and 3 simple steps and voila! If adding egg noodles to this dish, you will want to boil them beforehand, just like you would with a store-bought noodle.
What to Serve with Amish Chicken Casserole
This dish is easily paired with so many great sides. A simple green been is a perfect compliment, but we have also made a side of browned butter brussel sprouts, garlic potato wedges, or my personal favorite no yeast breadsticks!
Looking for More Casserole Recipes?
Dad’s Leftover Turkey Pot Pie Casserole
Tater Tot Hotdish (the only “hotdish” on the list!)
AMISH CHICKEN CASSEROLE
Amish Chicken Casserole uses flavor packed rotisserie chicken as a base and is topped with a savory and simple white sauce and perfectly cooked noodles.
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup butter
- 1/3 cup all-purpose flour
- 2 cups chicken broth
- 1 cup milk
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
- 8 ounces medium egg noodles, cooked
- 2 cups rotisserie chicken, shredded
- 8 ounces fresh mushrooms, sliced
- 1 small onion, chopped
- 2 tablespoons fresh parsley, chopped
- 1/4 cup parmesan cheese, grated
Instructions
- Pre-heat oven to 350°F and grease a 9x13-inch baking dish.
In a medium sauce-pan, make the sauce by melting the butter over medium heat. Whisk in the flour until no lumps remain.
- Stir in the broth and milk and bring to a boil. Reduce heat and allow to simmer until thickened. Stir in the salt and pepper. Keep warm on low while preparing the rest of the casserole.
- In a large bowl, add the noodles, chicken, mushrooms, onion, and parsley. Pour in the sauce and stir to coat. Transfer to the baking dish and sprinkle on the cheese.
- Bake for 25 minutes, until thoroughly heated. Serve immediately.
Recipe Video
Recipe Notes
TO STORE LEFTOVERS: Leftover chicken casserole can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days in an airtight container. Best if wrapped tightly in plastic wrap.
Did you make Amish Chicken Casserole?
I want to hear about it! Take a picture and tag me on Instagram or on Facebook. I would love to see your finished product! Make sure to tag me @iamhomesteader or hashtag #iamhomesteader, or both
Photography by The PKP Way.
Delicious, easy, and fast! As far as food goes, my husband is not difficult to please, but he loved this. After he had finished his first helping, he inquired as to what the sauce was. I explained that it was a basic white sauce, and he said that he loved it more than alfredo sauce (major wife points here). I have no idea on how it reheats, but if it doesn’t turn out well, I will probably halve the recipe next time as half of a 9×13 was perfect for just the two of us. Thanks Amanda & Patty for such a great recipe!
Would you please send me the ingredients for the cherry frosting, the one you put on the sugar cookies. The recipe for the frosting was not on the web site
I live alone and love to make new things. Can this be frozen?
Is this recipe okay for type 2 diabetics?
My husband has type 2 diabetes so I use whole grain noodles in place of anything that has white flour in it. Egg noodles do have white flour but it has a lot less than a regular pasta. I would say it is okay but maybe limit the amount of noodles and add more chicken or sub out the noodles for a whole wheat version or even a veggie pasta.
So much depends how many carbs he’s allowed. Try cutting it down to 6 ounces of noodles, you can get whole wheat if that works for him, and add extra chicken and mushrooms. Serve it with a green salad and some green vegetables and it should work.
How about using almond flour?
Thank you! Amanda
I love Amish food can I get the recipe for noodle salad
Can’t wait to try it. I think the Grandchildren will love it!
Do you cook the mushrooms first?
I sautéed the onions and mushrooms first while the noodles were boiling. I also added some nutmeg and garlic powder to the sauce. It was very good!
I found this recipe a bit bland for my family’s taste but it did taste good and was quite filling.
Can anything be substituted for the milk? I do not mix meat with dairy